Leave a comment

A THEOLOGY OF LUCK: Wishing You Good Luck in the Name of the Lord

There is an ancient Chinese fable that tells of an old farmer who lived many years ago. He had one old horse that he used to plough his fields. One day, the horse ran away into the hills. Everyone said, ‘We are so sorry for your bad luck.’ The old man replied, ‘Bad luck, good luck, who knows?’ A week later, the horse returned with a herd of wild horses, which now belonged to the old man. Everyone said, ‘We are so happy for your good luck!’ The old man replied, ‘Good luck, bad luck, who knows?’ While his only son was riding one of the wild horses, he fell off and broke his leg. Everyone said, ‘What bad luck!’ The old man replied, ‘Bad luck, good luck, who knows?’ One day, the army came to the village, and took all the strong young men to be soldiers for the emperor. Only the old farmer’s son was spared, because he could not fight with a broken leg. Everyone said, ‘What good luck!’ The old man replied, ‘Good luck, bad luck, who knows?’ 

Christians have often been suspicious of luck. The instinct is understandable. The biblical story testifies to a creation sustained by God rather than governed by blind fate. Yet perhaps the conversation is more complex than the simple alternatives of ‘God’s providence’ or ‘mere chance’. What if luck names something real about the world, even if it is not the whole story?

To begin with, we should acknowledge the obvious: people do not begin life on a level playing field. One child is born into financial security, another into poverty. One inherits robust health, another chronic illness. One happens to meet a mentor who changes the course of their life; another never encounters such an opportunity. To describe these realities as entirely self-made is absurd. They are, in a meaningful sense, matters of luck.

Contemporary philosophers such as Thomas Nagel and Bernard Williams have spoken of ‘moral luck’, recognising that outcomes are shaped by factors beyond our control. Curiously, this observation resonates with biblical wisdom. Ecclesiastes notes that ‘the race is not to the swift, nor the battle to the strong … but time and chance happen to them all’ (Ecclesiastes 9:11). Here Scripture itself appears to acknowledge an element of unpredictability woven into the fabric of existence.

Nor does Jesus seem particularly interested in explaining away unforeseen events. Indeed, he appears to assume them. Reflecting on the collapse of the tower of Siloam (Luke 13:1-4), Jesus rejects the suggestion that those killed were worse sinners than others. Tragedy strikes without moral calculation. Likewise the sun shines, and the rain falls, on both the righteous and the unrighteous (Matthew 5:45). Life does not distribute outcomes according to simple spiritual arithmetic. Jesus neither attributes every event to divine reward nor imagines that fortune and misfortune map neatly according to virtue and vice.

Perhaps then, luck is not an illusion but a feature of a contingent world. Contingency is something that might possibly happen in the future, usually causing problems or making further arrangements necessary. God has not created a mechanical universe in which every event is predetermined. Rather, creation possesses a genuine openness. Weather systems interact, human beings make free decisions, countless variables converge in ways that produce unforeseen outcomes. Luck may be the name we give to these intersections where possibility becomes actuality.

Theologically, however, luck need not rival God. We often assume that if luck exists, providence – God’s ongoing involvement in, care for, and governance of creation – cannot. Or if providence exists, luck must be an illusion. But this may be a false dichotomy. Just as gravity exists without displacing divine action, so unforeseen events may exist within a creation that remains held by God.

This perspective invites a more humble doctrine of providence. We need not claim that every parking space, successful job application, or sporting victory was specially arranged by Heaven. Sometimes people are fortunate. Sometimes they are unfortunate. The world contains an element of randomness that neither rewards virtue nor punishes vice.

Yet faith insists that luck is never ultimate. A person may be lucky and still live a shallow life. Another may be desperately unlucky and yet become wise, compassionate, and profoundly alive. The Christian claim is not that God eliminates chance, but that God’s redemptive purposes can work through, around, and despite it.

The story of Joseph (Genesis 37-50) illustrates this beautifully. A sequence of events unfolds that includes betrayal, coincidence, forgotten promises, and unexpected opportunities. Was Joseph lucky? At times he was extraordinarily unlucky. At other times he was remarkably fortunate. The narrative does not deny these realities. Instead, it suggests that God’s faithfulness is capable of weaving even the accidents of history into a larger story of blessing.

Paul develops a similar intuition, though in a distinctively Christ-centred way. He does not deny the fractured and contingent nature of the present age. Shipwrecks, imprisonments, illnesses, opposition, and disappointments punctuate his ministry. Paul is no advocate of spiritual fortune. Yet he holds stubbornly to the conviction that ‘all things work together for good for those who love God’ (Romans 8:28). Significantly, he does not say that all things are good, nor that all things are directly willed by God. Rather, God is able to work within the tangled complexity of human freedom, historical incidents, and worldly events to bring about redemption.

This leads to a subtle but important distinction. Luck may explain circumstances; it cannot explain meaning. It may help account for where we begin, what opportunities arise, or which obstacles appear in our path. But it cannot tell us what those circumstances are for, or how we should respond to them.

Indeed, Jesus’ proclamation of the Kingdom of God (Mark 1:15) suggests that God’s concern lies less in controlling every event than in forming people who can respond faithfully to whatever events occur. The fortunate are called to generosity. The unfortunate are offered dignity and hope. The Kingdom of God is not about escaping unforeseen events but about discovering God’s presence within them.

In this sense, Christian faith neither dismisses luck nor worships it. It accepts that contingency is part of creaturely existence whilst refusing to grant contingency the final word. The universe may contain chance, but it is not merely chance all the way down. The Christian hope is not that believers will be luckier than everyone else. It is that beneath fortune and misfortune, success and setback, coincidence and uncertainty, there remains a deeper reality: the steadfast love of God. Luck may influence the chapter we find ourselves in; providence is the confidence that the story itself has not slipped from God’s hands.

Perhaps, then, the theology of luck begins not by denying luck’s existence, but by putting it in its proper place. Luck is real enough as a description of life’s unpredictability. It may even be a genuine feature of God’s creation. But it is not a god, not a destiny, and not the final arbiter of human flourishing. Faith lives in the space where contingency and providence meet, trusting that while much in life is accidental, nothing is beyond redemption.

For Jesus (as we have already seen), the decisive truth was the coming Kingdom of God. For Paul, it was the revelation of God’s reconciling purpose in Christ (2 Corinthians 5:19). Both perspectives allow room for a world in which chance is real, fortunes differ, and outcomes cannot always be predicted. Yet both insist that beneath the flow of events stands a God who neither manipulates every detail nor abandons creation to chaos. Luck may help explain what happens to us. It cannot finally explain who we are, whose we are, or where the story is heading. Those questions belong not to fortune, but to faith.

I recall, many years ago, on a visit to Westminster Abbey, being given a ‘Welcome Leaflet’ on my arrival, by one of the Vergers. I confess to being rather disturbed (and somewhat amused) to read in the blurb that ‘The Dean and Chapter wish you “Good Luck in the Name of the Lord!”’ At that time (more than 60 years ago now) associating ‘good luck’ with God’s providence offended my embryonic evangelical faith. In hindsight, however, perhaps the Dean and Chapter were not as much off piste as I presumed at the time?

Jim Binney

Leave a Reply